NFT Photos

Photos as NFTs: The Picture Is Only the Wrapper

Right-click and save gets you a preview, not the photograph. How a photo sold as an NFT can carry the full file, its rules and the photographer's fee.

Photographers have heard it all about NFTs: that they are just pictures, that anyone can copy them, that the money was all speculation. Most NFTs were indeed digital collectibles, GIFs and JPEGs bought as speculative assets and traded on a marketplace, but that is a very narrow definition. NFT stands for Non-Fungible Token: each token is unique, and no two are identical even when they look alike. Fungible tokens are the opposite, like cash. A photographic print is the real-world version of non-fungible: one of an edition, never quite the same as another.

A cartoon foundry where gnomes mint NFTs: a Minting Station pours molten gold, while workbenches labelled Art Forge, Music Mastering and Cartoon Cultivator turn art, music and video into cards.

"Just right-click and save it"

Ethereum was the first blockchain where minting and reselling NFTs really took off. There were earlier experiments on Bitcoin, such as Colored Coins and Rare Pepes, but in 2017 CryptoKitties became so popular it jammed the Ethereum network. CryptoPunks arrived in 2017 and the Bored Ape Yacht Club in 2021, and marketplaces sprang up: OpenSea in 2017, Rarible in 2020 and Blur in 2022. Simple GIFs and JPEGs traded at incredible valuations based on mint number, scarcity and the rarity of their traits. In 2022 a CryptoPunk sold for about $23.7 million, as one of only nine rare "aliens" among the 10,000.

Critics' favourite jab was "just right-click and save it": anyone could copy the picture, so what was the buyer actually paying for? For a photographer the answer is easy. A right-click gets you the preview. The photograph is inside.

The full photograph, inside the token

Content delivery is the single most untapped use of NFTs. An NFT is normally thought of as one image file and some code, but the image file is just the wrapper: the part you see publicly and share on social media. Holding the token in your wallet is how you gain access to the contents, which could be a high-resolution image, an ebook, a music file or a video.

The rules of transfer can be set in the token, even permissionless incentivised replication, where a holder earns when their copy of the token is replicated. Every holder becomes a potential affiliate of the photograph they hold, and the photographer is paid on each replication.

The photographer's fee

Most NFTs got this wrong. On Ethereum, the creator's fee on a resale was only ever advertised by the token, and paying it was left to the marketplaces; once they made it optional, it mostly stopped being paid. WAX made the same mistake, trying to have creator fees enforced by the exchanges, when they should be enforced by the token itself. Ethereum (ERC-721C) and Solana (programmable NFTs) added forced fees in 2023, and Algorand has its own version (ARC-18), each by controlling who may move the token: an approved list of marketplaces, or a contract with an administrator.

The BRC-226 tokens we created on BSV work differently: anyone can buy a copy straight from the token itself, and the creator's fee on that sale is one of the token's own rules, enforced by the miners. The rules live in the token, not in someone's goodwill, and can never be changed: there is no administrator and no approved list of marketplaces. As far as we know, no other NFT works this way. NFT.sale is a marketplace that works on these tokens.

More than prints

ERC-721, the Ethereum standard for NFTs written in 2018, says as much:

NFTs can represent ownership over digital or physical assets. We considered a diverse universe of assets, and we know you will dream up many more:

  • Physical property — houses, unique artwork
  • Virtual collectibles — unique pictures of kittens, collectible cards
  • "Negative value" assets — loans, burdens and other responsibilities

In general, all houses are distinct and no two kittens are alike.

A photographer can sell more than prints. A ticket to an exhibition or a workshop: GET Protocol has issued tickets on a blockchain since 2016, more than 4 million by 2023; in 2022 Coachella sold ten lifetime festival passes as NFTs, and Ticketmaster gave every fan at Super Bowl LVI an NFT of their ticket as a souvenir. In my opinion tickets are still a very good use: a fake is caught at the door, because the door checks it against the blockchain; the resale price can be capped; the artist or venue can take a cut of every resale; a ticket can be refundable but non-transferable, so there is no scalping; and afterwards it stays as a souvenir.

A membership to a photo club, or a coupon for a print shop, works the same way. It can be traded with the club or shop earning a small percentage, set to expire, or kept by one holder only. The rules on how an NFT can be used, and by whom, are programmed into the NFT itself.

Even a framed print can travel as an NFT. The WAX blockchain set out to build vIRLs, "virtual in real life", for a "Post-Retail World": items bought as NFTs and held in storage until the holder asks for delivery, so they can be gifted or traded before anything ships. Funko, Hot Wheels and Bratz all sold vIRL NFTs; Bratz holders could claim the physical toy. Nike patented "CryptoKicks" in 2019, digital sneakers each linked to a real pair, bought the NFT studio RTFKT in 2021, and closed RTFKT down in January 2025. WAX itself was founded in 2017, largely on the idea of game items as NFTs, by the team behind OPSkins, then the leading marketplace for items from games such as Counter-Strike and Dota 2; items that work across many games rarely happened, because each game has to support the others'.

In closing

NFTs are probably the most important use of blockchain technology, and they go far beyond collectibles and speculation on digital scarcity. They will likely only become truly mainstream when they are as boring as a bus ticket or a bag of potato chips. That day is coming: when buying a print quietly means holding an NFT, everyone will own one without even thinking about it.